The Most Dangerous Room Is the One Where Everyone Agrees.

Ali Mazloum

16 November 2026 · Leadership · Short version on LinkedIn

In 1961, a room full of smart people agreed on a plan that failed within days. Why every plan needs someone to attack it before it goes out, and what that challenge can save.

In April 1961, President Kennedy approved the Bay of Pigs invasion.

His advisers were some of the smartest people in Washington, and almost all of them agreed with the plan. It fell apart in three days.

The problem wasn’t intelligence. It was agreement. Nobody in the room wanted to be the one who said, “This won’t work.”

Kennedy learned from it. A year later, during the Cuban Missile Crisis, he changed how decisions were made. He asked his advisers to argue against each other.

Sometimes he left the room so they would speak freely. That process is widely credited with keeping the world out of a nuclear war.

I think about this a lot in construction.

A schedule, an estimate or a design can look perfect when everyone around the table nods. The site is where it gets tested, and the site doesn’t care how confident we were.

So on any project, try one simple thing.

Before a plan goes out, ask someone to attack it. Have them find the weak spot and tell you what breaks first. Sometimes they find nothing.

The military calls this a red team.

The best time to hear "this won't work" is before you start, not after.

Disagree? Good. That is what the comments are for. Tell me where this goes wrong in your experience.

Try it yourself
Construction cost estimator · Voltage drop calculator
Share
LinkedIn ·

Comments

Verified people only. Real names preferred.

House rules

  1. A confirmed email address is required. It is never shown.
  2. Your first comment is read by me before it appears. After that you post directly.
  3. Argue with the idea, not the person. Off-topic and sales comments are removed.
  4. I moderate. Nothing here is published automatically.

Leave a comment

Comments are read by me before they appear.

We'll email you a link to confirm. Then it goes to me for a quick read.

Read next: They Only Hear One Idea